Home RecipesComfort Food Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese

by Adrianne

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese pasta recipe which is simple and made on the stove top in 15 minutes. For the creamiest, cheesiest blue cheese mac sauce without cream! This is a vegetarian recipe!

Wooden Spoon held above bowl with cheese dripping down

Whether it is a good old fashioned mac and cheese or a tasty Tomato Mac and Cheese these comfort food recipes are reminiscent of younger days! Fast cooking like the super easy Instant Pot Penne Pasta. Or oven baking like the Spinach and Ricotta Cannelloni give us mutliple techniques for making vegetarian pasta! 

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese is on the menu!

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese for a quick and easy comfort food meal.

Cooked macaroni pasta smothered in a cheddar cheese sauce topped with chives, cracked pepper and onion flakes.

This mac and cheese recipe is ridiculously easy. It is quick and it is so cheesy! 

Blue Cheese takes your regular mac and cheese to the next level of taste sensations.

I know you are going to have some questions about this recipe, so let’s get to them.

What is Mac and Cheese?

Mac and Cheese is the ultimate comfort food. It involves cooking macaroni pasta until al dente, then making a sauce to pour over and stir through.

Many recipes call for a bechamel sauce with melted butter, flour and milk. They are great options with taste and flavour.

I am not a huge fan however, of adding flour to sauces in all cases. This is one of those times.

For me, if I can make a creamy, dreamy and ultra cheesy sauce without the cream, I am ALL ABOUT IT.

You will remember recently from the Fiesta Tuna Pasta Bake recipe, that we talked about a creamy pasta bake which actually used greek yoghurt instead of cream.

I said it then and I will say it again HOLD THE CREAM! Say what, how do we make creamy, dreamy blue cheese mac and cheese without the cream?

Well my friends, let me tell you.

Mac and Cheese Sauce

For this stove top mac and cheese recipe to get the ultimate cheesy outcome, time was a huge priority for me.

I didn’t want to spend 30 minutes on a week night whipping this up, if I could refine it down to a 15 minute quick and easy dish.

The mac and cheese sauce needs to be creamy. It needs to be thick, cheesy and saucy. There are a few simple tricks we can do to achieve this. It is all in the technique.

As we are boiling the macaroni on the stove top, we are using water to boil the pasta.

We are then reusing this water in our mac and cheese sauce, well blue cheese mac and cheese sauce, to be exact.

Whilst our pasta is boiling away, we use this time to combine our sauce ingredients in a heat proof jug.

Our sauce ingredients are:

  • blue cheese 
  • cheddar cheese ( I used mozarella, cheddar cheese is popular in the USA)
  • greek yoghurt
  • onion flakes
  • left over pasta water

Then when the pasta is cooked, we strain it over a heatproof dish to reserve the water. We pour that water into our heat proof jug and we stir to combine.

The heat from the water will melt the cheese and then we are ready to pour and stir. It is SO, EASY!!

If the traditional bechamel (flour, butter, milk) is ingrained in you and you want to try that with evaporated milk, that is ok. I just ask you to consider if you want to try the best ever blue cheese mac and cheese recipe and if so, trust me and give this recipe a go!!

You can find all of the latest recipes on the blog here!  

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese sauce ingredients

What can I add to Mac and Cheese?

There are many varieties out there that put a spin on a traditional mac and cheese.

You can try:

  • adding bacon
  • adding chicken
  • panko bread crumbs
  • parmesan cheese
  • onion flakes
  • dried herbs (I used onion flakes)
  • cracked pepper
  • vegetables (although this doesn’t tick everyone’s comfort food box!!)


What is the best type of pasta to use?

There is no doubt that macaroni is the best type of pasta for mac and cheese. 

Macaroni is cheap to purchase, quick to cook and is the ultimate pasta to smoother with a thick cheesy sauce. 

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese sauce in a white pot


Macaroni with Blue Cheese Sauce with a wooden spoon

How do you make Mac and Cheese creamy again?

You have to have a few tricks up your sleeve with a recipe like this.

The blue cheese sauce will be melted and stretchy when you make it and stir it into the dish.

If you don’t manage to eat the whole batch of mac and cheese (it will be hard trust me) you will want to save some for later.

When you do go to heat and eat for round 2, you will notice that the sauce isn’t as thick and creamy as it once was. To get your mac and cheese to resemble the creamy delicious dish you originally made, you can use a little milk, stock or water. Simply reheat your pot and add the liquid then stir to combine. If using water, use only a little as it will dilute the rich blue cheese flavour and we definitely don’t want to do that!


Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese being stirred in white pot with a wooden spoon

What does Blue Cheese taste like?

Some people think that blue cheese tastes and looks like mould. It is a cheese after all so on a level, there is some truth in that. I remember years ago being skeptical as well, but if you have ever had buffalo blue cheese sauce with chicken wings, you will know how it feels to be converted.

If some of the blue cheese makes its way from your cutting board to your mouth whilst preparing it, that is ok, just make sure you save enough for the creamy sauce! 


How to cook Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese?

There are many recipes out there for mac and cheese that are oven baked. 

That is a great idea, when you have the time. For this recipe, I am picturing you coming home from work, to a busy house, you spy 30 mins on the clock before the crowd arrives and you want to fit in a sneaky glass of wine.

So, we boil our pasta, drain the cooked macaroni, spoon in our sauce, stir, reduce to a low heat, have a quick shower, pour yourself a wine and dinner is done.

Stove top mac and cheese for a busy night, save the oven baked mac and cheese for the weekend.


Wooden Spoon held above bowl with cheese dripping down

Can I stand in the kitchen with a spoon and eat this from the bowl?

Haha, of course, you can my friend!!

Not only will you be tempted to do this, it will nearly be IMPOSSIBLE to stop yourself from doing this. You can see that cheese dripping from the spoon in the above photo hey, YUP, that is what I am talking about!!

You and your ole mac n cheese will be best friends at the end of the cook time. Just don’t sit on the couch with your crock pot on your lap as it will burn your legs!!

It is entirely possibly that you will never make a regular mac n cheese again after you have tried the ultimate Blue Cheese Mac n Cheese version! It seriously is the cheesiest best out of all recipes blue cheese mac and cheese!

Close up shot of blue cheese mac and cheese

Close up into bowl of cooked blue cheese mac and cheese

Easy Family Friendly Recipes

Mac and Cheese is perfect for kids too! Don’t be surprised if blue cheese is not loved by little ones, it is after all, an acquired taste. Should you wish you can do half and half.

This simply means, making the sauce without the blue cheese, mixing that through some of the pasta for the kids. Then stirring the blue cheese into the other half of the sauce (microwave for 1 min if it has set a bit), and stirring that through for the big kids.

The pasta will take less than 10 minutes to cook. The sauce is made during that time. We pour the sauce onto the macaroni, stir it through. Get some texture into the dish with the onion flakes, pepper and chives, then eat, eat, eat!

 Kids will like a simple mac and cheese, so use the same pasta and add the blue cheese to the adults bowls only!

A couple of other easy pasta recipes that you may want to include in your weekly meal plan are:

Family friendly meals need to be loved by all and EATEN by all

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese close up Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese in small yellow bowl with spoon

Recipes from friends

One of my fellow Aussie Food Bloggers Kylie, knows her Mac and Cheese Recipes. So much so that her recipe for Sweet Potato Mac and Cheese is loved by kids everywhere!! Recipe is here.

.About the recipe:

  • The blue cheese mac and cheese is best served hot from the pot
  • You can reheat this dish
  • The macaroni will cook in less than 10 minutes
  • This is a stove top mac and cheese
  • The blue cheese sauce is creamy without using cream

Your quick questions answered:

  1. You can add a variety of liquids to make the sauce creamy again
  2. Macaroni is the best pasta for this dish
  3. For kids, stick to a basic mac and cheese
  4. You can add cooked bacon or chicken to the dish
  5. This is a SUPER EASY simple mac and cheese recipe

What to serve with mac and cheese?

Let’s face it. We are not enjoying this dish as we are working towards our bikini body.

This is a comfort food dish, that some people will run at the mere thought of.

We use:

  • blue cheese
  • cheddar cheese (or mozarella)
  • greek yoghurt

To name a few ingredients for our sauce.

I would recommend keeping it simple and indulging in a small bowl of this, without any sides. A glass of wine, will likely help you enjoy it!

Serve smaller portions of this recipe as it is packed with carbs, flavour and texture!

Reduce calorie intake

Mac and cheese is not diet food. It is comfort food. I serve much smaller portions of this than I would other recipes as the rich creamy texture is deliciously filling.  The nutritional information is shown below for the recipe, but here are some tips to reduce calorie intake:

  • Reduce the amount of pasta and add chicken
  • Add broccoli
  • Add peas
  • Increase the greek yoghurt and decrease the grated cheese
  • When reheating use water instead of other liquids

Alternate options

If you like the look of my photos, but blue cheese or pasta isn’t your thing.  These Chicken Recipes might give you inspiration:

Wooden Spoon held above bowl with cheese dripping down

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese

Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese for a quick and easy comfort food meal. Cooked macaroni pasta smothered in a cheddar cheese sauce topped with chives, cracked pepper and onion flakes.

5 from 9 votes
Print Rate
Course: Dinner
Cuisine: American, Australian
Keyword: blue cheese mac and cheese, mac and cheese
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes
Servings: 4
Calories: 427kcal
Author: Adrianne


Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese Recipe

  • 2 cups uncooked macaroni pasta
  • 1 tbsp dried chives
  • 1 tbsp cracked pepper
  • 1 tbsp onion flakes

Blue Cheese Sauce

  • 160 grams blue cheese
  • 1/2 cup greek yoghurt
  • 1/2 cup cheddar cheese NOTE 2
  • 1 tbsp onion flakes
  • 1/2 cup left over pasta water


Blue Cheese Mac and Cheese Recipe

  • Bring a medium sized 3/4 water filled dutch oven to the boil, add a splash of olive oil and cook macaroni till al dente (approx 8 mins). NOTE 1
  • In a heat proof jug add blue cheese, cheddar cheese and greek yoghurt.
  • When pasta is cooked, remove from heat, drain keeping the water and add pasta back to dutch oven.
  • Sitr 1/2 cup of pasta water into cheese sauce and stir to combine as cheeses melt
  • Pour cheese sauce over cooked macaroni, add onion flakes and stir to combine. Keep at a low heat until ready to serve.
  • Top with dried chives, cracked pepper and onion flakes.


  • Note 1: I don't use salt to cook pasta. I use a little olive oil. I would not recommend adding salt as the blue cheese is salty enough. A saucepan is fine to cook this recipe, I was excited to get my 1st dutch oven, so I tested it out! 
  • Note 2: To the shock horror of my American and Canadian friends, you can't really buy cheddar cheese in Australia. I used mozzarella, but recommend cheddar for those who can get it. For Aussies, mozzarella or regular grated (light) will do fine. 


Calories: 427kcal | Carbohydrates: 45g | Protein: 22g | Fat: 18g | Saturated Fat: 11g | Cholesterol: 46mg | Sodium: 663mg | Potassium: 294mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 4g | Vitamin A: 495IU | Vitamin C: 2.2mg | Calcium: 370mg | Iron: 1mg
Did you make this recipe? Share on Instagram!It makes my day when you make my recipes! Tag @sweetcaramelsunday

How Dutch is your oven?

A dutch oven is a great way to cook this recipe as it can be kept in the fridge and then reheated the next day for left overs. Using your crock pot is also an option.

If you don’t have one of those, a simple saucepan will do the trick!


Close up into dutch oven of blue cheese mac and cheese

Blue Cheese Mac anc Cheese in large pot with 2 small bowls in front

Pasta recipes

If comfort good is your thing (and I am guessing it is) then you will no doubt love the Beef Bean Pasta Bake that is another family favourite, with beef mince in a classic tomato sauce (recipe is here).

If Quick and Easy recipes are an asset to your cookbook, then check out my Fiesta Tuna Pasta Bake, (recipe is here).

For a recipe that grown ups will love, try my  Pimped Chicken Drumsticks  with espresso infused honey! Make a batch to heat and eat Monday to Friday!

I totally understand that time needs to always be of the essence in our lives. 🙂 My Pinterest Comfort Food Board is sure to give you some quick inspiration!

Show me your dishes!

I get a great thrill from seeing the recipes from the blog being recreated by the readers. I also love hearing from you and sharing my passion for food and cooking.


Food Blogging brings me happiness as I get to share my recipes with you (and no longer spam my friends with food pics!!).

If this is your 1st time on Sweet Caramel Sunday, welcome! It is my intention that you love the recipes and drool all over the computer when you are looking at the pics.

Adrianne xx

P.S. Give me a shout of you have any questions!

My top 3 recipes on the blog ranked by readers are:

  1. Crispy Chicken BLT Salad (recipe is here)
  2. Orange Cacao Bliss Balls (recipe is here)
  3. Vegan Brown Rice Noodles (recipe is here)

My personal favourite recipe on the blog is:


Instant Pot Penne Pasta Spinach and Ricotta Lasagna Tomato Mac and Cheese 

Comfort Food  Dinner recipes Popular recipes


You will also LOVE these recipes...


Shashi at SavorySpin June 6, 2019 - 8:42 am

5 stars
I don’t think I’ve had mac and cheese quite as exquisite as this! Loving that blue cheese and chive action you have going on here!

Adrianne June 6, 2019 - 8:59 am

Thanks Shashi, that’s a nice compliment, it tastes delicious!

Sylvie June 6, 2019 - 9:28 am

5 stars
Yes yes yes! You know I’m a sucker for anything pasta, and how could i resist to this creamy cheesy goodness!? My husband loves blue cheese so I think I’m gonna have to make this recipe for him asap!

Adrianne June 6, 2019 - 9:40 am

Indeed Sylvie!!! Hope you do, I am sure he will love it, cheers!

Jane Saunders June 6, 2019 - 9:35 am

5 stars
I’m on a quest to make my man the perfect Mac & Cheese – I haven’t quite found the perfect recipe yet. Yours is significantly different from so many out there – I’ve never considered not making a bechamel before, but your alternative is genius.

Adrianne June 6, 2019 - 9:42 am

Thanks Jane! I alway use Greek Yoghurt where I can!! Cheers for the feedback!!

Jacqueline Meldrum June 6, 2019 - 10:18 am

5 stars
Oh my! I’m there. Serve me up a big bowl please. sharing this now.

Adrianne June 6, 2019 - 10:23 am

No problem Jacqueline, it’s coming your way!!

Danielle Wolter June 6, 2019 - 10:36 am

5 stars
this sounds incredible! i am a huge lover of blue cheese and think i could eat a whole pot of this mac and cheese!

Adrianne June 6, 2019 - 10:46 am

I love your feedback Danielle, thanks!! It is hard to not eat it all!!

Lee -Ann June 9, 2019 - 3:05 am

The yoghurt is such a great idea, thanks for sharing!

Adrianne June 9, 2019 - 5:26 am

Cheers Lee-Ann, thanks for your feedback!!

Alexandra @ It's Not Complicated Recipes June 9, 2019 - 3:06 am

5 stars
I love mac and cheese! It is my ultimate comfort food, and I adore blue cheese – so much to love about this recipe!

Adrianne June 9, 2019 - 5:26 am

Cheers Alex, me too!!

Mikayla June 9, 2019 - 3:59 am

5 stars
Mac and Cheese IS the ultimate comfort food! I’m so surprised cheddar isn’t available in Australia, but honestly mozzarella is one of my favorites, so I think I’ll try it that way first!!

Adrianne June 9, 2019 - 5:27 am

Thanks Mikayla, love your feedback!! Yes, we have heaps of cheeses but not that one.

Jaimie @ Nosh June 10, 2019 - 12:02 am

5 stars
Put blue cheese in anything and I am sold! Can’t wait to serve this at my next barbecue!

Adrianne June 10, 2019 - 3:04 am

Great to hear Jaimie, thanks for that!

Gavin June 10, 2019 - 12:10 am

5 stars
Ooooooo blue cheese Mac n cheese – HELL YEAH!! Getting on this right away

Adrianne June 10, 2019 - 3:02 am

Haha thanks Gavin! Great to see another blue cheese lover.

Nicolas Hortense June 12, 2019 - 12:17 pm

The blue cheese idea is next level!! Making me so hungry!!

Adrianne June 19, 2019 - 10:22 am

Glad to hear that Nicholas!

canvasartstore June 19, 2019 - 8:42 am

What a delicious looking mac and cheese dish!

Adrianne January 27, 2020 - 7:44 am



Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.